Menu of MR SOFTEE STORE / HAMPTONS SOFT ICE CREAM INC in East Islip, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Nestled in East Islip, NY, MR SOFTEE STORE / HAMPTONS SOFT ICE CREAM INC offers a nostalgic dive into classic soft serve delights with a fresh twist. This ice cream shop, located at 195 Carleton Ave, stands out for its generous portions and authentic, no-frills charm. Whether you're craving a simple vanilla cone or an inventive specialty like the Ice Cream Burger or the decadent Choco Taco, you’re in for a treat that stirs childhood memories while satisfying modern cravings.

The menu boasts a diverse range, from hearty Banana Boats priced at $12.00 to $13.99, including options like the Dubai Strawberry Cup and Sundae, to specialty cones such as Caramel and Cookie Crunch, each hovering around $5.50. Their cones and cups category is equally tempting, featuring unique items like the Bubble Waffle and Coconut Cone, typically under $10, making indulgence accessible without overstretching the wallet.

What truly sets MR SOFTEE apart is the balance they strike between classic comfort and creative flair. The Choco Taco — a massive, peanut-crusted delight — seems to be a crowd favorite, embodying the brand’s commitment to delivering bold, memorable flavors without taking themselves too seriously. This establishment isn’t about artisan pretentiousness but about delivering soft, creamy, and delightfully messy ice cream experiences that resonate emotionally with customers.

Customer feedback highlights the warm, speedy service even during busy hours, and while the space is modest—lacking in seating—it compensates with a welcoming ambiance. Notes about the cleanliness and the nostalgic soft serve truck vibe, complete with merchandise like toy trucks and t-shirts, enrich the overall atmosphere. However, some patrons mention the need for more outdoor seating or tables to fully enjoy their treats on site.

Given its location in a small strip mall, parking and safety might require a bit of caution. Still, the abundant toppings, including standout options like strawberry shortcake crumbles versus traditional sprinkles, empower guests to customize their dessert adventure. It’s a place where you don’t just eat ice cream—you relive it. The large servings add value, making every visit a satisfying experience.

In summary, MR SOFTEE STORE / HAMPTONS SOFT ICE CREAM INC is a perfect pit stop for classic, playful ice cream lovers who want a nostalgic bite fused with generous portions and friendly service. Its unpretentious menu, coupled with specialty creations, keeps things exciting without losing sight of what makes soft serve special: simple joy.